KARACHI: A newly implemented point-based scoring system for clearing agents has sparked widespread concerns within the industry, with stakeholders warning of mass business closures and legal challenges.
Sharjeel Jamal, Convener of the Federation of Pakistan Chambers of Commerce & Industry (FPCCI), has strongly criticized the system, arguing that it unfairly penalizes agents and could force nearly half of them into the lowest category by June, effectively driving them out of business.
“This point scoring system is illegal,” Jamal said, explaining that under legal principles, an individual cannot be punished twice for the same offense. He pointed out that clearing agents merely process Goods Declarations (GD) based on information provided by importers and are often unaware of the exact contents of the consignments. Despite this, fines, penalties, and First Information Reports (FIRs) are regularly lodged against them. The introduction of the point system, he said, exacerbates this issue by imposing additional penalties.
Jamal further emphasized that customs agents operate under licenses issued by the authorities and play a crucial role at every stage of the clearance process. He urged decision-makers to acknowledge their position and responsibilities, advocating for the immediate suspension of the scoring system to prevent further disruptions.
The implementation of this system has raised concerns within Pakistan’s clearing and forwarding sector, with agents fearing a decline in operational stability and increased regulatory hurdles. As discussions continue, industry representatives are calling for a reevaluation of the policy to ensure fairness and transparency.
The FPCCI and other stakeholders are expected to push for official engagement on the matter, seeking a resolution that safeguards the interests of clearing agents while maintaining compliance with customs regulations.